Most of us have experienced deja vu—that sensation when new events feel eerily familiar. Could this "glitch in the Matrix" be a brain short-circuit?
Wait, have I been here before? Have we stood in this exact spot as you said these same words to me at some point in the past? Haven’t I seen this very cat pass by this very hallway already? Sometimes, as we experience a new event or place, we get that creepy feeling that it's not the first time. We call that sensation déjà vu, a French phrase that means "already seen." But what is déjà vu, and can science explain why it happens?
Déjà vu feels like a "glitch in the Matrix"
Some think déjà vu is a sign that you're recalling an experience from a past life. Spooky!
Carrie-Anne Moss, as Trinity in The Matrix trilogy, tells us (and Keanu Reeves as Neo) that déjà vu is a "glitch in the Matrix"—the simulated reality that keeps humanity unaware that intelligent machines have actually taken over the world. That explanation is perfect for cyberpunk science fiction, but it doesn't give us any scientific understanding of the phenomenon.
The very things that intrigue us about déjà vu are the same things that make it hard to study.
We associate the feeling of déjà vu with mystery and even the paranormal because it is fleeting and usually unexpected. The very things that intrigue us about déjà vu are the same things that make it hard to study. But scientists have tried using tricks like hypnosis and virtual reality.
Déjà vu could be a memory phenomenon
Scientists have tried to effectively recreate déjà vu in the lab. In a 2006 study by Leeds Memory Group, researchers would first create a memory for patients under hypnosis. That memory was usually something simple like playing a game or looking at a printed word in a certain color. Then patients in the different groups were given a suggestion to either forget or remember the memory, which could later trigger the sense of déjà vu when they encountered the game or word.
Other scientists have attempted to bring on déjà vu using virtual reality. One study found that participants reported experiencing déjà vu when moving through the virtual reality Sims video game when one scene was purposefully created to spatially map to another. (For example, all of the bushes in a virtual garden were replaced with piles of trash to create a junkyard with the same layout.)
Our brain recognizes the similarities between our current experience and one in the past.
These experiments have led scientists to suspect that déjà vu is a memory phenomenon. We encounter a situation that is similar to an actual memory but we can’t fully recall that memory. So our brain recognizes the similarities between our current experience and one in the past. We're left with a feeling of familiarity that we can’t quite place.
Beyond this general explanation, there are dozens of theories that attempt to explain why our memories might malfunction in this way. Some say it’s like a short in the circuits in our brain leading to long- versus short-term memory so that new incoming information goes straight to long term memory instead of making a stop in the short term memory bank. Others blame the rhinal cortex—the area of the brain that signals that something feels familiar—for somehow being triggered without the memories to back it up.
Another theory is that déjà vu is associated with false memories—memories that feel real but aren’t. This form of déjà vu would be similar to the feeling when you can’t differentiate between something that really happened versus a dream. However, researchers have begun to push back on this idea.
One study used functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) to scan the brains of 21 participants as they experienced a kind of lab-induced déjà vu. Interestingly, the areas of the brain involved in memory, like the hippocampus, were not triggered as we would suspect if the feeling was linked to a false memory. Instead, the researchers found the active areas of the brain were those involved in decision making. They interpret this result to mean that déjà vu could instead be a result of our brains conducting some form of conflict resolution. In other words, our brain checks through our memories like a rolodex looking for any conflict between what we think we’ve experienced versus what actually happened to us.
Déjà vu could be a temporal lobe issue
At the more extreme end of the déjà vu experience is temporal lobe epilepsy, a chronic disorder of the nervous system which manifests as unprovoked seizures in the temporal lobe of the brain. These seizures often take the form of focal-aware seizures. The person doesn't experience an altered level of consciousness but does experience abnormal sensations like déjà vu. Some scientists believe that every experience of déjà vu is at least a minor version of this disorder.
It's probably not precognition
Déjà vu is sometimes associated with getting a glimpse at the future, which adds to the creep factor. Some people experiencing déjà vu report feeling like they've not only lived this moment already, but they can predict what will happen next.
People experiencing a feeling of premonition are no more likely to be able to predict the correct outcome than when they are blindly guessing.
Science doesn't bear that out. Researchers have put this sense of premonition to the test and found that people experiencing a feeling of premonition are no more likely to be able to predict the correct outcome than when they are blindly guessing.
Is experiencing déjà vu something to worry about?
Should you be worried about déjà vu? As long as your déjà vu experiences aren't linked to a form of epilepsy, researchers have uncovered no reason to suspect any negative effects. In fact, some scientists believe déjà vu might actually be beneficial. If it is, in fact, a result of our brains reflecting on our memories and reorganizing anything filed incorrectly, then we might credit the eerie feeling as a sign our memory is in good working order. This idea aligns with the fact that déjà vu strikes mostly young people between the ages of 15 to 25.
Regardless of whether it's good or bad for us, we should all be grateful that the feeling of déjà vu is so fleeting. In the UK, scientists have been studying a young man in his 20s with what they call “chronic déjà vu.” The man frequently feels like he is reliving an experience, often for minutes at a time, a traumatic experience he compares to being trapped in the movie Donnie Darko. Yikes!
JOIN THE SCIENCE CONVERSATION
Have you experienced déjà vu? Tell me about it on Facebook or Twitter. If you have a question that you’d like to see on a future episode, send me an email at email@example.com. Keep up with new episodes by subscribing to Everyday Einstein on Apple, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.