'A' Versus 'An'

The rule for using "a" and "an" is actually more complicated than you may have been taught.

Mignon Fogarty,
A vs. An

'A Historic' or 'an Historic'?

While we’re talking about different pronunciations, let’s talk about "a historic.” Some Americans argue that it should be “an historic,” and one of the most contentious interactions I had at a book signing was over this point, but I come down firmly on the side that says it should be “a historic event.” 

Here’s my reasoning: Most people pronounce the H in “historic,” and there’s nothing special about the word. So if it starts with a consonant sound—an H sound—it gets an “a” in front of it like all the other words that start with a consonant sound. 

In some regions, people do drop the H. Linguists call this an unvoiced H, and in grad school, I had a professor from Boston who would say “istoric” instead of “historic. (He’d also say “uman” instead of “human.”) 

So if you say “istoric” or you grew up in a region where everyone says “istoric,” it’s reasonable that you might think it should be “an istoric” because to you, the word starts with a vowel sound. But, that’s not the common, standard pronunciation in most of the world, so unless you’re writing for a regional publication and all your readers call things “istoric,” it’s not the correct choice.

If you’re feeling argumentative about this point, I’ll direct you to the website (The Slot) of the late, great Washington Post copy editor, Bill Walsh, which has an exhaustive review of how different style guides deal with this word. But you should know that after reviewing many style guides, he also stood behind “a historic” being the correct choice.

For more on this topic, I address the word "historic" in greater depth in this post

Definite and Indefinite Articles

“A” and “an” are called indefinite articles, and the is called a definite article. The difference is that “a” and “an” don't say anything special about the words that follow. For example, think about the sentence, “I need a gum drop.” You'll take any gum drop—just a gum drop will do. But if you say, “I need the gum drop,” then you want a specific gum drop. There must be something special about that one, specific gum drop you are requesting. That’s why “the” is called a definite article—you want something definite. At least that's how I remember the name.

That’s your Quick and Dirty Tip: It’s the sound of the next word, not the first letter of the next word, that determines whether you want “a” or “an.” Consonant sounds call for an “a,” and vowel sounds call for an “an.”

Mignon Fogarty is Grammar Girl and the founder of Quick and Dirty Tips. Check out her New York Times best-seller, “Grammar Girl’s Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing.


Additional Reading

Review by The Slot of "a" and "an" Before "Historic"

Image from Notestagram

text with a quiz for the difference between a and an


The Quick and Dirty Tips Privacy Notice has been updated to explain how we use cookies, which you accept by continuing to use this website. To withdraw your consent, see Your Choices.