Do you really need to take fish oil? Nutrition Diva explains.
Fish Oil and Omega-3s
By now, almost everyone has heard about the omega-3 fatty acids in fish and how important they are for your health. But some people don’t care for fish and even those who like fish often don’t eat it every day. That probably explains why fish oil is now among the top-selling nutritional supplements.
In fact, the demand for fish oil has gotten so huge on the strength of the omega-3 story, that now there are serious concerns about the effects of over-fishing. And just last week, there was a big scandal when it was discovered that some well-known brands of fish oil contained unacceptable levels of PCBs.
Should You Take Fish Oil?
Now, a lot of people are wondering what to do. A colleague of mine actually stopped me in the hall last week to ask my advice: Were she and her husband better off without the fish oil supplements, she asked, or did the health benefits of the omega-3s outweigh the risk of chemical exposure?
Actually, I have a slightly different perspective on omega-3 fats—one I bet you haven’t heard in the popular press. Omega-3s are very important to your health. However, you don’t necessarily need to increase your intake in order to get the benefits.
What Are Omega-3 Fatty Acids?
Before I explain, many of you may think I’ve overlooked an obvious solution. Certain seeds, including flax, hemp, and chia, are also rich in omega-3s. I haven’t forgotten about these other sources of omega-3 fats. But the kind of omega-3 found in these seeds isn’t as potent as the form found in fish oil.
Omega-3 actually refers to a whole family of fatty acids. At the top of the family tree is alpha-linoleic acid, or ALA. It’s the most common kind of omega-3, but it’s also the least biologically active. In order to get the most benefit from ALA, your body first has to convert it to other omega-3s like EPA and DHA. That conversion process isn’t terribly efficient. Depending on the circumstances, only a small fraction of ALA may actually get converted into the turbo-powered EPA and DHA forms.
Why Is Fish Oil Good for You?
The advantage of fish oil is that the fish have already done this conversion for you. Flax oil contains a whole bunch of ALA but almost no EPA or DHA. Fish oil, on the other hand, contains ALA but also lots of EPA and DHA. So, flax doesn’t necessarily have the same benefits as fish or fish oil.
But the alternate solution I’m going to propose has another clever benefit. Not only does it allow you to get more benefit from less omega-3, it also helps make your body more efficient at converting ALA into EPA and DHA, so it makes these vegetarian sources of omega-3 more valuable.
What are Omega-6 Fatty Acids?
The reason that we’re all being told to eat more omega-3s is that your body works best when you have a balanced intake of omega-3s and omega-6s.
OK, by now, you’re probably pretty curious about what I’ve got up my sleeve. But, first, I need to clear up a little misconception about another family of fatty acids called omega-6. I bet you’ve heard about them too.
The reason that we’re all being told to eat more omega-3s is that your body works best when you have a balanced intake of omega-3s and omega-6s. For most of us, though, our intake of these two families of fats is anything but balanced. Unlike the omega-3 fats, which are sort of few and far between in the food supply, omega-6 fatty acids are everywhere you turn.
Which Foods Contain Omega-6 Fatty Acids?
Vegetable oils such as corn, peanut, and soybean oils are very high in omega-6 fats. Because these oils are inexpensive, they are widely used in food processing and manufacturing. As a result, most of us get a lot of omega-6 in our diet, and not that much omega-3. But I don’t want you to get the idea that omega-6 are somehow bad. They’re not. They are just as essential as omega-3s. In the body, they have opposing but complementary functions.
Balancing Omega-3 and Omega-6: the Lemonade Method
It’s a little like making lemonade. You need both sweetener and lemons to make lemonade. But lemonade only tastes good when the sweet and tart flavors are properly balanced. Let’s say you have a whole bunch of sweetener. You could go out and buy a truckload of lemons and make a lot of lemonade. Or, you could use only a portion of the sweetener, in which case you’d need far fewer lemons to make your lemonade.
I’m sure you see where I’m going with this: Our modern diets are like lemonade made with way too much sweetener. We get way too much omega-6 fat. To correct this, we’re being told to add more lemons, or omega-3s, to balance it out. I hardly ever hear anyone suggest that could accomplish the same thing by eating less omega-6.
How to Limit Your Omega-6 Fatty Acids
I’ve got some links below that you can explore for lots more information on this topic. For example, you can look up the omega-6 and omega-3 content of foods or analyze the balance of your diet on Nutritiondata.com. But my quick and dirty tip for this week is that you’ll need less omega-3—and will get more benefit from vegetarian sources of omega-3—if you cut back on your omega-6 intake.
Here are a few tips on how to do this:
Use olive or canola oil: In the kitchen, use olive or canola oil instead of other vegetable oils.
Read labels: Read labels on processed foods and cut back on those that contain vegetable oils, including corn, soybean, peanut, sunflower, or safflower oils, especially if they contain more than a few grams of fat per serving.
Watch out for seeds: Sunflower seeds, sesame seeds, pine nuts, and peanuts are all rich in omega-6. You don’t need to avoid them altogether but eating a lot of these foods will increase the amount of omega-3 you need to maintain a balance.
You can post comments and questions below, on my Nutrition Diva Facebook Page, or on Twitter. I answer a lot of listener questions in my free weekly newsletter, so if you’ve sent a question my way, be sure you’re signed up to receive that.
Have a great week and remember to eat something good for me!
PCBs in Fish Oil (CBS News)
Is Taking Fish Oil Environmentally Irresponsible? (Nutrition Data Blog)
Eat More Fish: What’s a Vegetarian to Do? (Vegetarian Journal)
The Importance of the ratio of omega-6/omega-3 essential fatty acids (Journal article)
Is Canola Oil Healthy? (Nutrition Diva article)
When to Use Olive Oil (Nutrition Diva article)